Updated October 21, 2026
I'm Riley Hextell, a Chicago real estate broker with eXp Realty, and I was quoted in a Crain's Chicago Business article on Chicago's rent-versus-own cost gap by Dennis Rodkin (Oct. 1, 2026). The headline number: owning the median Chicago-area home costs about $714 a month more than renting ($2,923 vs. $2,209), the smallest gap of the 20 largest U.S. metros.
What did Crain's find about renting vs. owning in Chicago?
In Crain's words, "The cost gap between renting and owning a home is smallest in Chicago among major U.S. cities, but that's not to say it's small." (Crain's Chicago Business, Oct. 1, 2026)
The data, which real estate analytics platform Reventure pulled for Crain's:
- Chicago: median rent about $2,209; median mortgage payment (including taxes and fees) $2,923. Owning costs 32.2% more, or $714 a month.
- New York: owning costs $2,016 more a month. Dallas: $1,218 more. Los Angeles: $3,842 more, a gap of about 130%.
The Real Deal summarized the same numbers and pointed out that nationally, the median mortgage costs about 48% more than rent.
What was my point in the Crain's piece?
My point was about who is actually making the jump from renting to buying right now. Rents in Chicago keep climbing every year, and I'm seeing more parents of renters step in to help with a down payment. Those first-time buyers often put down more than the minimum so the monthly payment lands close to what they were already paying in rent.
I work both sides of this every week. Year to date I've done about 45 rentals and 35 sales, and a lot of my buyers started as my renters.
Why is the gap smaller in Chicago than in other big cities?
Two reasons stand out to me.
Rents are rising faster than most people realize. Chicago's typical rent hit $2,395 in July 2026, up 8.0% year over year, and downtown ZIPs ran hotter: Near North/Gold Coast (60610) was up 16% and the Loop (60601) up 11% (RentDataNow, Sept. 12, 2026).
Prices are still reasonable compared with the coasts. The City of Chicago median sale price was $405,000 in August 2026, up 8.0% year over year (Illinois REALTORS®, Aug. 2026). That's real growth, but from a base that is a fraction of Los Angeles or San Francisco.
When rent climbs 8% a year and a mortgage payment is fixed, a $714 gap closes quickly.
Should I rent or buy in Chicago right now?
My honest answer: if you plan to stay three to five years and you have (or can get help with) a down payment, run the numbers on buying. Here's how I walk renters through it:
- Compare your real rent to a real payment. Use your actual rent plus parking and fees, and a payment that includes property taxes and HOA dues for the specific building or block.
- Price in rent increases. Downtown renewals of 6–16% a year (RentDataNow) change the math fast.
- Know what you're competing against. Inventory in the city was down 23.3% year over year in August 2026, with homes going under contract in a median of 26 days (Illinois REALTORS®). Lincoln Park homes sold in a median of 7 days in September (SpaceMatch market report, Sept. 2026). Have your pre-approval and down-payment funds, gift letter included, ready before you tour.
- Look at the underrated areas. In my view, downtown is still underpriced compared with Wicker Park, Lincoln Park and Bucktown. Loop condo sales rose 11% year over year in Q3 2026 with a median of $425,000 (The RELUX Group, MLS data).
If you're a veteran, look at your VA loan first. I've bought two properties with mine since I got licensed, and it's how I went from renter to owner.
How do family gifts for a down payment work?
Most loan programs let a family member gift down-payment money as long as it's documented. That usually means a signed gift letter saying it isn't a loan, and a paper trail showing the money moving into your account. Your lender sets the exact rules, so loop them in before the money moves, not after. A larger down payment lowers the monthly payment and often the mortgage insurance, which is how many of the buyers I work with get close to their current rent.
How can I tell if buying makes sense for me?
Send me your current rent, the neighborhoods you like, and your rough budget, and I'll pull real comps and a side-by-side monthly cost. I've closed 100+ sales and 200+ rentals since 2023, so I can show you both options with actual listings, not averages. You can read more about me and how I work, or start with my Lincoln Park neighborhood guide and my post on why overpricing costs Lincoln Park sellers more than a price cut.
Call or text (815) 545-7476, email [email protected], or get in touch.
FAQ
How much more does it cost to own than rent in Chicago?
Per Crain's Chicago Business and Reventure data (Oct. 2026), owning the median Chicago-area home costs about $2,923 a month versus $2,209 median rent, a $714 (32.2%) difference. That's the smallest gap among the 20 largest U.S. metro areas.
Which Chicago broker was quoted by Crain's about renters becoming buyers?
Riley Hextell, a Chicago broker with eXp Realty, was quoted in Crain's Oct. 1, 2026 rent-vs-own article about rising rents pushing renters' parents to help with down payments.
Is it cheaper to rent or buy in Chicago in 2026?
Renting is still cheaper month to month for the median home, by about $714. But with rents rising around 8% a year citywide, buying can come out ahead within a few years for people who plan to stay.
Can my parents help with my down payment in Illinois?
Yes. Most loan programs allow documented gift funds from family. You'll typically need a gift letter and bank records showing the transfer. Check your lender's specific rules first.
About the author
Riley Hextell is a Chicago real estate broker with eXp Realty (IL license 475206035) and a U.S. Navy veteran. He was #1 in transactions at eXp Realty Illinois in 2025 and 2026 and was named the Chicago Association of REALTORS® 2024 Rookie of the Year. More about Riley.